Untimely World Pictures
Images of the Earth, Histories of Geopower
University of Toronto Press, 2027
Summary
Contemporary media and culture are permeated by images of the earth as a measurable and malleable globe. This imagery crystallizes the dominant world picture underlying the Anthropocene, in which the planetary environment is offered up to human design and depletion. To explore alternative forms of planetary imagining, this book turns to images of the earth in historical art and visual culture. Approached as untimely—at once historical and alive in the present—these representations offer complex counters to dominant framings of the earth. I develop this argument through extended visual analyses of a selection of world pictures in dialogue with theories of geopower—the ways in which states, empires, and classes assert power over the planet. I focus particularly on three case studies, drawn from diverse periods and sociopolitical settings: Hieronymus Bosch’s late-medieval vision of the earth set before God’s gaze, with humans embedded in creation rather than beholding it from without; the personification of the earth in seventeenth-century Andean painting, in which it appears as an unmastered female sovereign who unsettles colonial extractivism; and the socialist artist Walter Crane’s nineteenth-century imagining of global revolution as heralding a renewed flourishing of planetary life, beyond economic utility. Attending to these past paradigms of depth and complexity in imagining the earth opens up new possibilities for interrogating geopower, connecting historical apprehensions of the earth with today’s fraught landscape of geopolitical struggle and ecological derangement. While far from being utopian alternatives that can simply be redeemed in the present, these untimely world pictures offer ways of recognizing planetary agency, imagining not more eyes on the earth but the eyes of the earth.
